Garrett Clayton on His Low-Key Wedding Night with Blake Knight: 'The Walking Dead' and Ice Cream

Speaking to PEOPLE at Freeform's Halloween Road event in Los Angeles Thursday, the Teen Beach Movie star, 30, dished on the couple's low-key evening, complete with TV and dessert.

"We kind of just think married life feels the same at the moment," he said. "Even our wedding night, he was like, 'Do you feel different?' and I was like, 'No, do you feel different?' and he said, 'No.'"